History that YouTube thinks is offensive

Home Forums News & Current Events History that YouTube thinks is offensive

This topic contains 4 replies, has 3 voices, and was last updated by  Atypical Sapien 1 year, 5 months ago.

  • Author
    Posts
  • #8320

    corsaire
    Participant

    The History Guy posts well researched videos on long lost historical events.  Apparently there were pictures that were deemed “inappropriate”.  The History Guy explains

    I saw the original video and looked fine to me

  • #8321

    corsaire
    Participant

    Ok so for whatever reason, I cant c/p the narrative under the video.

  • #8322

    corsaire
    Participant

    fixed

    The is the same exact episode that was posted last October, with a few changes in the pictures. YouTube “de-monetized” the first posting, and, as is their unconscionable policy, has refused to provide any explanation. I have changed some photos in a good faith attempt to understand their bizarre and opaque application of poorly described community guidelines, moving a photo that, while I maintain was never shocking and clearly presented within historical context, might be the reason for the claim that the video was deemed “not advertiser friendly.”

    To be 100% clear: This is an educational episode about actual historical events. Nothing in the episode is presented without clear context. There is no intent, whatsoever, to shock or offend. There is no presentation of gore or violence except in the clear and obvious context of the important historical events. If any member of any YouTube team seeks to restrict this video in any way, have the common decency of emailing me at thehistoryguyyt@gmail.com describing the precise information or image that supposedly violates a policy. Please do not just link community guidelines that do not explain why certain episodes have been targeted.

    I do not believe that I have ever presented any episode of THG on YouTube with intent to shock or offend, nor have I presented gore or shocking images gratuitously. I do not believe that it is in the interest of YouTube, its creators, advertisers or viewers, to block the presentation of history because history is often shocking in its very nature. Remembering history is important, and plays a vital role in society. It should not be censored. Sensibilities should not move in society such that we cannot remember the past simply because the past has often been difficult. If we neglect to learn these lessons, the future will be made much more difficult.

    If the viewer believes that the information in this episode is appropriate and provides value, please say so in the comments. If you see a reason that such a video should not have the benefit of advertising, I do respect all opinions, and ask that you make a clear argument and indicate a time-stamp for whatever information you think crosses a line. I am truly and respectfully seeking solutions where YouTube, which has offered me an extraordinary platform and connected me to my wonderful audience, has refused to help creators in a meaningful way.

    If you feel that content such as this should not be censored, please consider my Patreon page. http://www.patreon.com/thehistoryguy.

  • #8335

    namelus
    Participant

    No sense to fight you tube so many have tried just mirate to different platforms.

  • #8459

    Atypical Sapien
    Participant

    FWIW: This is one that won’t be shown on main stream media but is still on YT:

    Make Mine Freedom Cartoon from 1948 is still pertinent today.

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bhtq13ACvU8

You must be logged in to reply to this topic.

Skip to toolbar